The Prisoner's Dilemma on The Bachelor PadWell, it is classic and actually multiple prisoners, but the choice is that of one prisoner. So the apostrophe is in the right place.
It is a sorry fact that I did not watch 'The Bachelor Pad', though I do tend to watch 'The Bachelorette', and found out about this from an economics blog. (h/t Cheap Talk). The analysis of the other players is very entertaining. I know I would pick 'Share', but I am that stupid.